Peer Review - not for the short sighted. Josh 87

More cartoons by Josh here

Comments

[Phillip Bratby]

Another great cartoon. Josh you really are on top form. I listened to the first programme in the series yesterday. All the way through I kept thinking when are they going to discuss Climategate, the hockey stick, hide the decline etc?.

[KnR]

To be fair what’s being shown is a rather extensive review , from the ‘Teams’ point of view, normal the reviewer may not actual be required to have seen the document to know the ‘quality ‘ of its work , the authors name being the most important element .

[Vigilantfish]

Brilliant. I think this portrayal of a reviewer peering short-sightedly at an upside-down paper could be applied more generally to climate science, and to a Mann paper in particular - the Tiljander sequence.

[Brian Anderson]

One of the reasons why I like visiting your blog so much is because it has become a daily reference I can use Viagra Canada in order to learn new nice stuff. It's like a curiosities box that surprises you over and over again.