Has the Graun backed down?
Jul 29, 2010
Bishop Hill in Climate: WG2, Greens, Media

Richard North is given space at Comment is Free to vent his spleen at George Monbiot.

An honest commentator would be joining us to ensure that the unsubstantiated claim by the IPCC is removed. But Mr Monbiot has instead resorted to ad hominem abuse which he – or his employers – justify as "fair comment".

Rather, he should be concerned, even if for entirely different reasons, that the response of the IPCC to a proven and egregious error has not been healthy. And an organisation which cannot admit error and deal with it is one that cannot be trusted.

The same might also be said of its supporters who, instead of dealing with the entirely justified criticisms, seek to attack the critics. By their deeds shall we know them and, in respect of his particular deeds in relation to "Amazongate", we have come to know Monbiot quite well.

Do we gather that Dr North's complaint to the PCC has been successful?

Article originally appeared on (http://www.bishop-hill.net/).
See website for complete article licensing information.