Update on Jun 22, 2010 by
Bishop Hill
Bishop Hill
McIntyre's take on the Kelly paper is here.
The most interesting of the attachments to Professor Hand's emails is a paper by one of his fellow panellists, Michael Kelly, who is Professor of Electronics at Cambridge.
The paper records Professor Kelly's impressions as he reads through some CRU papers. I can't really do justice to this paper as a short summary. For the moment, I've extracted the relevant pages from the full download and you can just read it. I think Steve M will probably have something to say on Kelly's work, which seems fairly frank.
The download is here.
Bishop Hill
McIntyre's take on the Kelly paper is here.