Revkin on Steig and O'Donnell
Dec 31, 2010
Bishop Hill in Climate: Surface, Journals

Andy Revkin looks at O'Donnell et al's recent improvement on/rebuttal of Steig et al, the 2009 paper that suggested that the whole of the Antarctic was warming. Revkin sees the appearance of the rebuttal as reinforcing his faith in the peer review process, a marked contrast to the views of Richard Smith, which were discussed here a couple of days back.

Article originally appeared on (
See website for complete article licensing information.