What do you make of this?
Nov 22, 2009
Bishop Hill in Climate

This email was written by Michael Mann shortly after the publication of McIntyre and McKitrick's 2003 paper in Energy and Environment. The various members of the Hockey Team were trying to formulate a response. Mann first thanks Osborn:  

Thanks very much Tim,

 I was hoping that the revisions would ally concerns people had.  I'll look forward to your comments on this latest draft. I agree w/ Malcolm on the need to be careful w/ the wording in the first paragraph. The first paragraph is a bit of relic of a much earlier draft, and maybe we need to rethink it a bit. Takinig the high road is probably very important here. If *others* want to say that their actions represent scientific fraud, intellectual dishonesty, etc. (as I think we all suspect they do), lets let *them* make these charges for us!

   Lets let our supporters in higher places use our scientific response to push the broader case against MM. So I look forward to peoples attempts to revise the first par. particular.

   I took the liberty of forwarding the previous draft to a handfull of our closet colleagues, just so they would have a sense of approximately what we'll be releasing later today--i.e., a heads up as to how MM achieved their result...

   look forward to us finalizing something a bit later--I still think we need to get this out



  So who are the supporters in higher places. And who are the "closet colleagues" (or does he mean "closest"?)




Article originally appeared on (http://www.bishop-hill.net/).
See website for complete article licensing information.